• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe – Best Soft Serve & Frozen Custard in Dexter, NY

Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe, nestled in Dexter, NY, offers a standout experience with its rich and creamy soft serve frozen custard. Known for unique flavors like peanut butter soft serve and inventive swirls such as black raspberry and Dole whip, this charming spot delights locals and visitors alike. The shop blends classic hard ice creams, sundaes, and generous toppings with friendly, attentive service, led personally by the proud owner. Its waterside patio adds a perfect touch for savoring treats. Lickety Split’s dedication to quality and community makes it a must-visit for anyone craving exceptional, affordable ice cream.

Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe at a glance

  • Address 215 Water St, Dexter, NY 13634, United States
  • Phone +1 315-804-8008
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
  • Popular for Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe: Reviews & Ratings

Jen GUNN-RUSSELL
5

Loved the ice cream! Actually the soft serve custard was a wonderful surprise, it was amazing!!! I was in town for a family reunion and unfortunately discovered this place with a few days left in our trip. I say unfortunately because I wish we found it at the start of the trip we would have been there every day. In fact, we had to visit on our way out of town on a cold wet day when ice cream really isn't what you want to eat, that's how good it is, I just wish I lived closer!

Edward Richardson
5

Great little hometown ice-cream place. The soft serve is frozen custard and very rich and creamy, they also have a good variety of hard flavors, sundaes and other typical ice cream shop favorites.

Thanh Spitale
5

If you're up in dexter, this is a must stop. Amazin and friendly staff, and the selection of ice cream and topping was great. Wasn't to sure on the swirl black rasberry and dole whip, but let me say that it was perfect! They have patio tables right next to the water for everyone to enjoy.

luke Kampnich
5

Lickety split is highly recommended if you want the greatest ice cream around. The employees there are beyond great and always very polite. The owner is always right there working with everyone else and takes great pride in his establishment. Which he should because they are in my book the best ice cream in best pricing around. Thank you lickety split and I'll see you soon.

Mark Gayne
5

Amazing ice cream, better than all the rest! Peanut Butter soft serve is the absolute best!

Stephanie Gates
4

The soft serve is really good! Did not love the flurry but that is just personal opinion. The location is great right next to lake/river. My husband thought the prices were high but I thought they were comparable to nearby locations.

Gary Shatraw
5

Awesome ice cream served by great people. The portions are large. A medium cone is a challenge with a large just intimidating. Sundaes and flurries have plenty of options to satisfy any cravings you might have. Hard ice cream selection is pretty good too. Lines are common but move quickly. Worth the wait and I never stand in line. One of the best spots in the area.

Location

  • Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe
    Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe
    215 Water St, Dexter, NY 13634, United States Hotline: +1 315-804-8008

Nestled on 215 Water St in Dexter, NY, Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe is a true gem for ice cream lovers seeking a rich and satisfying treat. This cozy shop combines hometown charm with an exceptional menu that features the standout soft serve frozen custard—creamy, smooth, and decadently rich. It’s no surprise that patrons describe it as a wonderful surprise and a must-try on their visits.

What sets Lickety Split apart is not just the luscious frozen custard but also the thoughtfully curated variety of hard ice cream flavors and classic sundaes. The staff’s warm, friendly service creates an inviting atmosphere, making each visit feel personal and special. The owner’s visible pride and hands-on approach resonate through every scoop, elevating this shop above typical ice cream parlors.

Highlights like the peanut butter soft serve reveal a mastery of flavor balance—creamy with just the right hint of nutty richness that keeps customers returning. The adventurous swirl options, such as black raspberry and Dole whip, showcase the shop’s willingness to innovate while maintaining quality. Enjoying your ice cream on their scenic patio by the water adds a perfect touch to the whole experience, blending a sense of place with indulgence.

In sum, Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe is a standout destination that marries quality, variety, and community spirit. Whether you’re a local or a traveler passing through Dexter, it’s an essential stop to savor some of the area’s best frozen delights.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Dine-in
    • Same-day delivery